Performance Review SOP
A performance review SOP is a documented procedure that outlines the standardized steps, criteria, and timelines for conducting employee performance evaluations within an organization.
Read summarized version with
What is a Performance Review SOP?
A performance review SOP is a standard operating procedure that lays out exactly how an organization handles employee performance evaluations. It covers the review timeline, evaluation criteria, rating scales, and documentation requirements. The whole point is making sure every employee gets assessed through the same process, which keeps things fair and consistent across the company.
So why bother documenting all of this? Without a clear performance review SOP, managers tend to wing it. One might zero in on metrics while another cares mostly about teamwork. Some run hour-long conversations, others rush through reviews in fifteen minutes. This inconsistency creates real headaches, both for employees who feel the process is arbitrary and for organizations trying to make defensible decisions about promotions and raises.
A thoughtfully designed performance evaluation procedure also offers legal protection. When promotion or termination decisions get challenged, having documented proof that the same process applied to everyone carries significant weight. And it removes much of the uncertainty for new managers who might otherwise have no idea where to begin. This type of procedure typically falls under broader HR standard operating procedures that govern people management activities.
Key Characteristics of a Performance Review SOP
- Defined Review Cycle: Specifies when reviews occur, whether annually, semi-annually, quarterly, or some mix. Most organizations require reviews within 12-13 months of the last evaluation.
- Standardized Criteria: Lists the competencies, behaviors, and metrics that apply to each role or job level so everyone gets measured on the same things.
- Rating Framework: Establishes a consistent scale, whether 1-5 ratings, letter grades, or descriptive categories, along with clear definitions for each level.
- Clear Responsibilities: Outlines what managers, employees, HR, and leadership each need to handle during the review process.
- Documentation Requirements: Details which forms need completing, where they get stored, and how long records must be retained.
Performance Review SOP Examples
Example 1: Annual Review Process
A mid-size company's performance review SOP might require managers to keep running notes throughout the year, then complete a formal evaluation form in December. The employee submits a self-assessment first. The manager reviews both documents before the meeting, applies a five-point scale for each competency, and submits the completed review to HR within two weeks. Calibration meetings happen at the department level to ensure ratings stay consistent before compensation decisions get finalized.
Example 2: Continuous Feedback Model
A tech company uses quarterly check-ins rather than one big annual review. Their SOP requires managers to meet with each direct report in January, April, July, and October using a standard agenda template. The October session includes goal-setting for the coming year. Feedback gets logged in the company's HR system within 48 hours of each meeting, and employees can add their own comments to the record.
Performance Review SOP vs Employee Handbook
Both documents touch on performance management, but they serve different purposes.
| Aspect | Performance Review SOP | Employee Handbook |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | Managers and HR | All employees |
| Purpose | How to conduct evaluations | What to expect from the process |
| Detail Level | Step-by-step procedures with forms | General overview of policies |
| Focus | Execution of the review process | Rights and expectations during reviews |
The employee handbook might mention that reviews happen annually and that employees can respond to their evaluation. The SOP tells managers exactly when to kick off the process, which system to use, and how to handle disagreements.
How Glitter AI Helps with Performance Review SOPs
Glitter AI makes creating and maintaining performance review SOPs easier by letting HR teams record their screen while walking through the actual evaluation process. Rather than writing procedures from memory, you capture the real workflow, including which system screens to use, where to click, and what information goes where.
When the review cycle changes or the HR system gets upgraded, updating the SOP becomes straightforward. Just record the new process and Glitter generates fresh documentation with annotated screenshots. New managers can follow along visually instead of parsing through dense text documents, which speeds up training and cuts down on mistakes during a process that really matters to employees.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a performance review SOP?
A performance review SOP is a standard operating procedure that documents the steps, criteria, timeline, and responsibilities for conducting employee performance evaluations in a consistent and fair manner.
What should a performance review SOP include?
A performance review SOP should include the review schedule, evaluation criteria, rating scales with definitions, required forms, manager and employee responsibilities, documentation requirements, calibration process, and appeal procedures.
How often should performance reviews be conducted according to SOPs?
Most performance review SOPs call for annual evaluations, though many organizations also build in quarterly check-ins or semi-annual reviews. The SOP typically specifies that reviews must be completed within 12-13 months of the previous evaluation.
Why are performance evaluation procedures important?
Performance evaluation procedures ensure consistency and fairness across the organization, provide legal protection for employment decisions, reduce manager bias, set clear expectations for employees, and support objective compensation and promotion decisions.
How do you write a performance review SOP?
Start by documenting your current review cycle and timeline. Add the evaluation criteria and rating scales. Spell out who does what and when. Include the forms and systems used. Get input from managers and HR, then test the procedure during an actual review cycle.
What is the difference between a performance review SOP and a performance management policy?
A performance management policy states the organization's approach and expectations around performance evaluation. A performance review SOP provides the step-by-step instructions for actually carrying out that policy, including specific procedures, forms, and timelines.
How do performance review SOPs reduce bias?
Performance review SOPs reduce bias by requiring managers to apply the same criteria and rating scales for all employees, documenting specific examples to back up ratings, including calibration sessions where ratings get compared, and creating paper trails that can be reviewed.
What are examples of performance evaluation procedures?
Examples include annual review processes with self-assessments and manager evaluations, quarterly check-in procedures, 360-degree feedback collection processes, goal-setting and tracking procedures, and calibration meeting protocols.
How often should a performance review SOP be updated?
Review your performance review SOP at least once a year, or whenever you change HR systems, modify evaluation criteria, update rating scales, receive feedback about process issues, or face legal or compliance changes affecting documentation requirements.
What tools help create employee review standard operating procedures?
Tools for creating performance review SOPs include documentation platforms like Glitter AI that capture procedures from screen recordings, HR information systems with built-in workflow documentation, SOP software with version control, and collaborative document editors.
Turn any process into a step-by-step guide